You have permission to edit this article.
Edit
Commentary: Gov. Cuomo's cringeworthy COVID victory lap
AP

Commentary: Gov. Cuomo's cringeworthy COVID victory lap

Only $5 for 5 months
New York Governor Andrew Cuomo speaks during a COVID-19 briefing on July 6, 2020, in New York City.

New York Governor Andrew Cuomo speaks during a COVID-19 briefing on July 6, 2020, in New York City. (David Dee Delgado/Getty Images/TNS)

New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, no stranger to producing embarrassing political posters, has done it again, this time saluting his own leadership and the achievements of New York in the coronavirus crisis.

If New Yorkers could die from cringing, its chief executive would've caused a new public health crisis.

It is true that Cuomo has done many of the right things over the past four months, and that this is a moment in which New York, having beaten back its caseload and overcome its death spike, looks better than Florida, Texas, Arizona and other states where cases are spiking and deaths are increasing.

Cuomo wants to remind us of this, I think, to try to congratulate the people of his state on a significant achievement - complying with Albany-ordered shutdowns, bending the curve and saving lives - giving them a well-deserved boost of morale after a difficult stretch.

But it is never wise to gloat like this in the midst of a raging pandemic, and not like this.

Not when New York's death rate still far, far, far exceeds the rates in the other states in question. Yes, Sun Belt deaths will likely rise as the virus rips through nursing homes, as it already has here, but they're highly unlikely to approach the Empire State's.

Not when the governor and New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio, for all their willingness to listen to public health officials, made many errors that almost certainly contributed to that death total.

Not when the virus could easily come roaring back, as it has in California and Michigan, despite proactive gubernatorial leadership there, a point Cuomo emphasizes all the damn time. There but for the grace of the virions and our fellow Americans go we.

Not when Cuomo, who put the brakes on especially worrisome indoor dining in New York City, has allowed it to go forward in Long Island and Westchester, despite similar public health risks in those locales.

Now, can we talk for a minute about the imagery in the tableau, which the governor spent about six minutes earnestly explaining on Monday, after he waxed rhapsodic about old posters like a famous one supporting William Jennings Bryan?

Yikes. If the Bryan poster, complete with its octopus controlling the economy in what at least today feels like an anti-Semitic trope, was the gold standard, Cuomo's homage is made of tin foil.

It's one thing to show an image like this to try to win legislators over to the state budget or to celebrate one's accomplishments with tongue half in cheek; it's another to paint oneself and one's state as the conquering heroes of a pandemic that by any honest measure has laid us low.

There's the large quote across the top by, yes, one "Gov. Andrew Cuomo," chiding the rest of the country for failing to be as smart as he's been.

There is a line of masked essential workers, seemingly on loan from a Diego Rivera WPA mural, pulling down the curve, joined by the governor's daughters and dog, because of course they are.

There's a table at which Cuomo and three supporting cast members, awkwardly caricatured and unmasked, sit, with the words "New York Leads Again" in front of them. (True: We led in coronavirus deaths.)

There's a giant banner proclaiming "Love Wins" - yes, really - over a rainbow. At least he didn't get it trademarked.

There's Cuomo in a muscle car.

There's a picture of "The Sun On the Other Side," where apparently we are now, despite looming risk and New York City being told it's not going to get back to normal for some time. De Blasio is saying school will come back in a hybrid model in the fall; Cuomo's saying not so fast. This is a moment for pausing to write in the history books?

And at the center of it all, there's a mountain steeper than any in the Adirondacks. This was modeled after the actual three-dimensional foam mountain Cuomo unveiled last month, like something a sunburned Richard Dreyfus might frantically mold out of mashed potatoes.

Cuomo wants us to believe we together climbed that peak and then descended it, presumably to soak our feet in bath salts when reaching basecamp.

Not a gravestone appears anywhere in this awkward spectacle, nor does the number of New York dead, which exceed 32,000.

There's a reason most people who are very, very proud of themselves, who want to cement their legacies, get others to give them glowing introductions, then act humble when they walk up to the podium. Puffery is profoundly unbecoming; that's one lesson that the presidency of Donald Trump ought to have driven home.

___

ABOUT THE WRITER

Josh Greenman is the New York Daily News editorial page editor. Email: jgreenman@nydailynews.com.

Visit New York Daily News at www.nydailynews.com

Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

We have been asking the wrong question as we consider dipping our toes into new activities during the coronavirus pandemic: Is it safe? We are looking for a yes or no - a binary answer that harks back to our pre-pandemic lives. Instead, we should evaluate our encounters objectively based on some simple factors that place exposure on a risk spectrum. If we do, we will consolidate our successes ...

In recent weeks, American banks have denounced systemic racism and pledged support to Black lives. Yet their practices during this pandemic and their role in distributing money from the $660 billion Paycheck Protection Program show how systemic racism is embedded in their business model. Last week, the Trump administration finally disclosed the names of many companies that received forgivable ...

The Washington Redskins came to the realization - albeit belatedly - that doing the right thing is more important than clinging to archaic norms and has finally agreed to change its name after years of protests. That evolving mindset must now extend to schools and other institutions that are still exploiting live animals as mascots - a relic of an unenlightened past. Is there any animal more ...

It can be hard to remember here in the grasp of the coronavirus pandemic, and amid President Donald Trump's persistent displays of arrogant incompetence, that this whole Trump Era is at heart one massive grift. The most recent entry: a report that Trump financial backer and current ambassador to Great Britain, Robert Wood Johnson IV, made inquiries at Trump's request into whether the British ...

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.

Topics